As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. It never costs you more.
Prices checked October 2026Not tested in handNo paid rankingsHow we pick
You give up: A squared-off brushed-metal look rather than Smeg's rounded 1950s shape, for about $55 less.
Short answer: The closest cheaper alternative to the Smeg 50's Retro Style 2-Slice Toaster (TSF01) is Breville the Toast Select Luxe (BTA735), about $220 instead of $275 (save 20%). What you give up: A squared-off brushed-metal look rather than Smeg's rounded 1950s shape, for about $55 less. The cheapest is the Hamilton Beach Contemporary 2 Slice Toaster (22977J) at about $20. Prices checked October 2026.
Why it's a good swap A 2-slice toaster with 6 bread presets, 'Lift & Look' and 'A Bit More' buttons and an LED countdown, in metallic finishes and 11 colors.
You give up: A squared-off brushed-metal look rather than Smeg's rounded 1950s shape, for about $55 less.
Why it's a good swap Wide slots, 7 shade settings, a bagel setting and Toast Boost to lift small items, in Steel Blue or Sandstone.
You give up: Hamilton Beach doesn't list defrost or reheat, and it has none of the Smeg's retro styling.
Why it's a good swap Wider 1-1/2 in slots than the Smeg's 1.4 in, a bagel setting and a high-lift lever, per KitchenAid.
You give up: 5 shade settings against the Smeg's 6, and a lower 3.9-star rating on KitchenAid's site.
Why it's a good swap A metal 2-slice toaster with 7 shade settings, Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Little Longer functions, and a high-lift lever.
You give up: Its slots are slightly narrower at 1-19/64 in against the Smeg's 1.4 in, and it runs at 900 W against 980 W.
Typical US prices, checked October 2026. Not live prices; check the listing before you buy.
Looking for a cheaper alternative to the Smeg 50's Retro Style 2-Slice Toaster (TSF01)? It usually sells for about $275. Here are 4 cheaper swaps from $20: Breville the Toast Select Luxe (BTA735) is the closest match from another brand and the Hamilton Beach Contemporary 2 Slice Toaster (22977J) is the cheapest at about $20. Each one says what you give up for the lower price.
Worth it if you want a retro 2-slice toaster that matches Smeg's kettles: Smeg lists 6 browning levels, reheat, defrost and bagel functions, 1.4 in slots with self-centering racks, and 980 W on 120 V. T3's tester found every slice came out right on the regular setting and called the bagel function a standout.
If the toast matters more than the 1950s shape, the KitchenAid 2 Slice Toaster (KMT2109) ($180) has 7 shades with Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Little Longer, and Breville the Toast Select Luxe (BTA735) ($220) adds 6 bread presets and an LED countdown. For thick bread on a budget, the KitchenAid 2-Slice Toaster with Manual Lift Lever (KMT2115) ($80) has 1-1/2 in slots, and the Hamilton Beach Contemporary 2 Slice Toaster (22977J) ($20) covers the basics with 7 shades.
| Option | Type | Typical price | You save | What you give up | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smeg 50's Retro Style 2-Slice Toaster (TSF01) | The original | $275 | – | – | View ↗ |
| Hamilton Beach Contemporary 2 Slice Toaster (22977J) | Budget pick | $20 | $255 (93%) | Hamilton Beach doesn't list defrost or reheat, and it has none of the Smeg's retro styling. | View ↗ |
| KitchenAid 2-Slice Toaster with Manual Lift Lever (KMT2115) | Budget pick | $80 | $195 (71%) | 5 shade settings against the Smeg's 6, and a lower 3.9-star rating on KitchenAid's site. | View ↗ |
| KitchenAid 2 Slice Toaster (KMT2109) | Close match | $180 | $95 (35%) | Its slots are slightly narrower at 1-19/64 in against the Smeg's 1.4 in, and it runs at 900 W against 980 W. | View ↗ |
| Breville the Toast Select Luxe (BTA735) | Close match | $220 | $55 (20%) | A squared-off brushed-metal look rather than Smeg's rounded 1950s shape, for about $55 less. | View ↗ |
Typical US prices from retailer listings and price trackers, checked October 2026. They are not live Amazon prices and may have changed, so check the listing before you buy.
The Hamilton Beach Contemporary 2 Slice Toaster (22977J), at about $20 (93% less). Wide slots, 7 shade settings, a bagel setting and Toast Boost to lift small items, in Steel Blue or Sandstone. The catch: Hamilton Beach doesn't list defrost or reheat, and it has none of the Smeg's retro styling.
Breville the Toast Select Luxe (BTA735), at about $220 (20% less). A 2-slice toaster with 6 bread presets, 'Lift & Look' and 'A Bit More' buttons and an LED countdown, in metallic finishes and 11 colors. The catch: A squared-off brushed-metal look rather than Smeg's rounded 1950s shape, for about $55 less.
The KitchenAid 2 Slice Toaster (KMT2109) ($180) is a metal 2-slice toaster with 7 shade settings and Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Little Longer functions, close to the Smeg's 6 levels with reheat, defrost and bagel. Its slots are slightly narrower, at 1-19/64 in against 1.4 in.
No. In the US Smeg Store the 2-slice TSF01 was $275 and Smeg's 4-slice toasters were $330 when we checked in November 2026. Buying from the Smeg Store adds a second year of warranty, for 2 years in total.
The KitchenAid 2-Slice Toaster with Manual Lift Lever (KMT2115) ($80) lists 1-1/2 in slots, wider than the Smeg's 1.4 in and the KitchenAid KMT2109's 1-19/64 in.
T3's tester called the bagel function a standout and got a perfectly toasted bagel every time. Smeg's bagel setting browns one side only; KitchenAid's KMT2115 instead cuts one side's heating element by 50% to gently brown the outside.
Each swap links to amazon.com. Prices are typical US prices checked October 2026 and change often, so check the listing before you buy.
Every swap is a product sold in the US that does the main job of the original. Close match is another brand with similar features, Same brand, cheaper is an older, smaller or renewed model from the same maker, and Budget pick is the cheapest thing that still does the job. On each page, Closest match is the close match nearest the original in price, and Lowest price is the cheapest swap. We compare published specs, retailer listings and reviews; we don't test products ourselves.
A cheaper product is cheaper for a reason. Each swap says what you give up, like weaker noise cancelling, a smaller screen or a shorter warranty, so you can decide if the savings are worth it.
Prices are typical US prices from retailer listings and price trackers, last checked October 2026. They are not live Amazon prices, which change often. When a price couldn't be confirmed, the page says “Check price on Amazon” instead of showing a number.
Amazon buttons are affiliate links: Cheaper Swap earns a small commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. Commissions don't decide what is listed. Google AdSense may also show ads on the site.